A construction worker may spend twenty years building Dhaka’s apartments, offices and roads. Yet, a serious injury could leave him without wages, adequate compensation or a reliable way to support his family. His contribution to the economy is visible everywhere. His claim to economic security is far less certain. Such situation raises the uncomfortable question: does receiving assistance, or even qualifying for it, mean a person is protected? Bangladesh has made considerable progress against poverty. According to World Bank’s 2025 Poverty and Equity Assessment, moderate poverty fell from 37.1 per cent in 2010 to 18.7 per cent in 2022. But the assessment also found that roughly half of the poorest households received no social assistance in 2022, while some better-off households received benefits. Economic progress and programme expansion have not produced dependable protection against illness, unemployment, disability or disaster.
The country does not lack a policy vision. Its National Social Security Strategy (NSSS), adopted in 2015, proposed coordinated protection across different stages of life. More than a decade later, why has that ambition not translated into clear guarantees? Part of the answer lies in how success is defined. Governments can report how many allowances were distributed, households registered or taka spent. These figures describe administration, not necessarily security. An older person may receive an allowance too small for essential medicines. A flood-affected household may get emergency cash yet lose its livelihood for years. A worker may enrol in a scheme but struggle to claim benefits. Coverage is measurable; but protection must be tested against the risks actually facing people. That test should include whether benefits arrive before families sell productive assets, withdraw children from school or borrow at punishing rates. Protection delivered after irreversible damage may still provide relief, but it has failed at prevention, which should be its first purpose.
There is also a political economy behind fragmented assistance. Different ministries and agencies administer benefits, eligibility lists and budgets. Announcing new programmes is visible, but integrating schemes, correcting exclusion errors and creating effective appeals systems attract less attention. Where access depends on selection rather than clear entitlement, people cannot reliably plan around support. Such arrangements can also create opportunities for influence and unequal treatment, without implying every programme is mismanaged.
Universal social protection needs a precise meaning. It does not require identical payments to everyone or abandon priority for the poorest. It means that people facing defined risks can expect appropriate minimum support. Tax-financed assistance should protect those unable to contribute; insurance can share risks among workers, employers and the state, and public services remain indispensable. The shift is from hoping to be chosen as a beneficiary to knowing what protection one can claim.
Informal employment makes this difficult but unavoidable. Construction labourers, domestic workers, agricultural workers, street vendors and the self-employed may have changing employers, seasonal incomes or no payroll records. Who contributes to injury insurance when someone works for several contractors? How does a rickshaw driver maintain coverage during a month without earnings? Copying formal-sector insurance models could widen the divide between protected and unprotected workers.
Bangladesh’s Universal Pension Scheme, launched in 2023, offers a test of whether voluntary contributions can be sustained across irregular working lives. Proposals for wider social insurance deserve similar scrutiny. Flexible payments, portable records and subsidies for low earners are more credible than assuming everyone can contribute regularly. Those unable to pay still need tax-financed minimum protection.
The Family Card initiative raises another question: does registering a household identify every individual’s needs? A woman may have limited control over household income. An older relative may receive little support despite living with employed family members. Migrant workers may move between districts. Digital identification can improve delivery, but a card cannot replace individual assessment, adequate benefits or accessible appeals. Success should be judged by whether support reaches people promptly and follows them when circumstances change, not by cards distributed.
Financing cannot be avoided. Bangladesh cannot promise comprehensive protection without identifying its cost and who will pay. Better targeting and fewer overlapping schemes may free resources, but cannot finance meaningful guarantees alone. The composition of social security expenditure also deserves scrutiny, particularly the distinction between government pensions and transfers to households facing acute insecurity. Budget totals can conceal whose risks receive priority.
The practical choice is to define an affordable minimum package, protect its funding and expand it as revenues permit. Progressive taxation, appropriate employer contributions and subsidised insurance can share costs more fairly. International experience offers useful lessons. Thailand’s universal health coverage, introduced in 2002, demonstrates how public financing can extend essential protection beyond formal employment. Brazil’s Bolsa Família programme, supported by its unified social registry, illustrates how coordinated identification and predictable transfers can improve assistance delivery. Neither is a complete solution. Thailand shows why informal workers need publicly financed services; Brazil demonstrates the administrative advantages of integration. Bangladesh needs accessible services, reliable income support and accountable institutions, rather than simply more programmes.
Reform should begin with three commitments. Specify minimum benefits and eligibility in plain language. Publish reliable information on exclusion, payment delays and benefit adequacy. Give people functioning appeals channels when systems fail. An updated, secure social registry and climate-responsive payments can help, but technology is a means, not the guarantee itself. Article 15(d) of Bangladesh’s Constitution recognises public assistance in specified circumstances, although it does not itself establish an individually enforceable claim. Translating that principle into practical entitlements requires legislation, financing and accountability. The proposed NSSS framework for 2026-2035 should be judged by progress on those obligations rather than announcements. Bangladesh has spent decades counting how many people escape poverty. It must now ask how many can withstand injury, illness or lost income without falling back. Social security should not depend on political favour or administrative luck. A genuine system begins when citizens can count on protection when they need it most, rather than merely hope to be selected for assistance.
_____________________________________
The writer is an academician and development strategist, currently serving at a foreign diplomatic mission in Dhaka.
He can be reached at [email protected]