Joe Biden has finally told us what he knew. In his new memoir, Promise Me, America, the former president says Netanyahu ignored US calls to reduce civilian deaths in Gaza, made empty promises, and put his own political interests first. He describes a pattern. Netanyahu would promise to do more, and then another aggressive action would follow, killing more civilians. He says Netanyahu made promises he had no power or intention to keep. He also says he was frustrated that Netanyahu would not act as a statesman.
These are serious charges. But they come late, and they come from the wrong person.
Biden was not a bystander. He was president. He knew, by his own account, that he was being misled. Yet his administration kept the weapons, the money and the diplomatic cover flowing. Critics note that his memoir gives no sign he thinks the US should have fundamentally reconsidered its military support for Israel. Reports say he in fact defends that aid.
So a hard question remains. If you know a partner is deceiving you, why do you keep handing him more? Biden had leverage and could have set limits. He chose not to use it. Gaza was reduced to rubble, its people buried beneath it, and the fire spread across the region. American interests and those of its allies were damaged along with it.
Biden’s admission now has a certain value. It confirms what many already saw. But it does not wash his hands. A leader who says “I knew” is not confessing to being deceived. He is confessing to being complicit.
The scapegoat trap
A convenient story is now taking shape, and we should refuse it. In this story one man is the villain. Netanyahu lied, Netanyahu manipulated, Netanyahu exploited American generosity. Remove him, or simply blame him, and everyone else can move on with a clear conscience.
That would be a comfortable lie.
Netanyahu is not a rogue actor who hijacked a reluctant superpower. He is the face of a much larger system. That system includes the governments that supplied bombs and shells. It includes the officials who vetoed ceasefire resolutions. It includes the lawmakers who cheered every aid package and the commentators who explained away every atrocity. Behind them stand the diplomats who kept saying “Israel has a right to defend itself” while the death toll climbed. Every patron of this war now has a reason to point at Netanyahu. If he alone is guilty, then they are only guilty of being fooled. Fooled leaders are not criminals. They are victims. This is the exit the powerful are building for themselves.
If we accept that framing, the responsibility cannot sit on one man’s shoulders. A catastrophe of this size takes many hands. It takes money, weapons, political protection and silence. Netanyahu supplied the orders. Others supplied the means and the cover.
The scapegoat also serves a second purpose. It lets the machinery survive. If Netanyahu is the problem, then the policy is fine and only the person was bad. Washington can go back to business as usual with a ‘better-behaved’ partner. The weapons keep moving. The vetoes keep coming. The next atrocity begins on the same foundation as this one.
What Washington should learn
The people who now run Congress should read Biden’s memoir as a warning. They are not in his seat, but they inherit his choices and his habits. They can repeat them or break them.
The first lesson is that unconditional support buys no influence. Biden gave Israel almost everything it asked for, and received almost nothing in return. Promises were made and broken, and the cost of breaking them was zero. A patron who never says no is not a partner. He is a supplier at best, and a subordinate at worst (using euphemism here).
The second lesson is that aid needs conditions, and conditions need enforcement. American law already limits arms transfers to those who block humanitarian aid or violate the laws of war. Those laws were treated as suggestions. If Congress wants to avoid another memoir full of regret, it should enforce them now, not after the next disaster.
The third lesson is that the truth should be spoken while it can still change events. Biden’s frustration was real, but he voiced it in private, and publishes it now for profit and legacy. Gazans could not wait for his book contract. Officials who see a policy failing should say so while the policy can still be altered.
The real test
Washington has a long habit of discovering, or revealing, as the case may be, the truth just after leaving office. Memoirs arrive like confessions. They are written with candor and regret, and they are read when it no longer matters. Meanwhile the machinery and atrocities go on, with no clear end in sight.
The test for today’s leaders is simple. Will they learn from a failure they can still correct? Or will they wait, as their predecessors did, and write about it later?
Blaming Netanyahu is easy. Changing American policy is hard. Only one of them will save lives.
