Epaper ☀️ 🌐 English বাংলা Russian Hindi Chinese
×

Follow Us

Today's Newspaper

Bhashani’s (Mis)calculations behind Boycotting 1970’s Polls

Rajib Kanti Roy

Rajib Kanti Roy

Published: 17 Nov 2026, 12:00 AM

Bhashani’s (Mis)calculations behind Boycotting 1970’s Polls
A A

Despite wearing an ordinary white punjabi, a checked lungi and a straw cap, Maulana Abdul Hamid Khan Bhashani has been one of the most colourful characters of Bangladesh’s history. His combination of religious orthodoxy and socialist political ideas earned him the title “Red Maulana”, regardless of inconsistencies in many of his major political decisions. Why he and his National Awami Party (NAP) refused to take part in the 1970 elections still remains an unresolved riddle to many. Today, on the 50th death anniversary of the great Majlum Jananeta (leaders of the oppressed), let’s look back to search for the answer to this question. The question seems imperative because Bhashani’s withdrawal helped Sheikh Mujibur Rahman secure an overwhelming mandate in the polls held on 7 December 1970, paving the way for the political confrontation that culminated in Bangladesh’s Liberation War.
NAP’s fragmentation and departure of prominent leaders
Bhashani, who co-founded Awami Muslim League in 1949 and established National Awami Party (NAP) nine years later, was among the most influential mass leaders. But his political influence was considerably greater than his ability to organise and maintain party discipline, as evaluated by historian Srinath Raghavan in “1971: A Global History of the Creation of Bangladesh”. 
His organisational weakness manifested in fragmentation of his own party. In 1966, NAP was split into two factions, leaving Bhashani leading NAP (Bhashani) and Muzaffar leading the NAP (Muzaffar) in 1966. By the 1970 elections, it was separated into five groups. NAP general secretary Mohammad Toaha broke with Bhashani in May 1970 over the debate on Islamic and scientific socialism, while another popular leader, Abdul Haq, resigned from the party and Krishak Samiti the next month.
According to Raghavan, a council of NAP (Bhashani) was held in August 1970 in Khulna, where one faction led by Anwar Zahid, Nurul Huda Kader Box, Mohammad Sultan and Haji Danesh favoured contesting the election, while the other, backed by Abdul Matin and Alauddin Ahmed, advocated a boycott. At the council session, Mashiur Rahman Jadu Mia was elected the party’s new general secretary.




Bhashani, however, did not clear his position regarding participation in the polls. Referring to Bhashani’s electoral speech ahead of the polls on the radio along with other parties’ top leaders, Mohiuddin Ahmed in his “Rajnitir Maulana” states, “Although Maulana Bhashani delivered what could be described as an ‘election speech’, he did not speak about the election or campaign for his party’s candidates. He remained silent during the heated debate over whether to participate in the election at the party’s council session in Khulna, but his inclination was towards staying out of the polls. Rather than explicitly calling for an election boycott, however, he demanded solutions to the problems facing peasants and workers. He questioned whether the election would bring any benefits or liberation to the poor and working people. At the time, he raised the slogan ‘voter age vat chai’ (want food before voting).” Many believe that while announcing withdrawal from the polls, Bhashani understood that the resignation of some popular leaders weakened the party and disputes within it would not bring an expected result.
Financial limitations and declining support from the business community
Lack of funding could be another reason for Bhashani’s boycott of the elections, as polls have always been a “money game” in this part of the world. Ahead of the 1970 general elections, East Pakistani businessmen and industrialists favoured Awami League over NAP because Mujib’s platform did not advocate the wholesale abolition of private ownership and promised a competitive atmosphere for Bengali businessmen, whereas Bhashani’s leftist policies threatened radical economic restructuring. Besides, consistent inconsistency in Bhashani as a politician also could erode their trust in him. In his book, “The Bangladesh Revolution and Its Aftermath”, Talukder Maniruzzaman reveals that 19 per cent of Awami League’s National Assembly candidates in 1970 came from business and industrial groups, an unusual trend for that time. He also discusses the backing of Bengali businessmen and industrialists for the nationalist movement, hoping for endless opportunities if the country obtains independence.
Anger against West Pakistan’s indifference to humanitarian disaster
Among all the reasons, the merciless indifference and failure of the West Pakistani authorities in standing by the victims of the deadliest Bhola cyclone could be the most important one. The catastrophic cyclone that struck the coastal belt on 12 November 1970 left an estimated 3,00,000 to 5,00,000 people dead, devastating communities across Hatiya, Sandwip, Bhola and other coastal areas. The accompanying storm surge swept away thousands of livestock and destroyed huge quantities of crops, leaving survivors facing an unprecedented humanitarian crisis.
Sheikh Mujibur Rahman visited the worst-hit areas, blaming authorities for their sluggish attitude in assisting cyclone-affected people. Bhashani, who was receiving medical treatment at the time, visited the affected Hatiya and witnessed the devastation firsthand. Returning to Dhaka, he condemned the government’s indifference, capturing the growing resentment against West Pakistan’s political leadership.
According to “Bengali Nationalist Movement and the Liberation War” by Mahfuzur Rahman, police baton-charged a procession on 18 November when demonstrators demanded that the affected areas be declared disaster-hit zones. Addressing a rally at Paltan on 23 November, Bhashani made his famous remarks, “Ora keu ashe nai (none of them has come)”, criticising the West Pakistani political leaders who had not come to see the people of East Bengal in that hour of distress. A day later, Bhashani announced his decision to boycott the December elections if it is not postponed as the cyclone left thousands of survivors homeless and without food, shelter and medical assistance. Yahya Khan, however, on 27 November announced that the election would proceed as scheduled only except the cyclone-hit areas.
Mahfuzur Rahman, however, argues that Bhashani’s decision was rooted in a broader political calculation, as he observed that participating in the election would make little difference on the basis of his earlier experience of winning the 1937 Assam Legislative Assembly election and the 1948 East Bengal Legislative Assembly by-election.
The book acknowledges the government’s handling of the disaster generated widespread anger, and thus, influenced the election negatively. Many people who had opposed Awami League before the cyclone subsequently shifted their allegiance to the party and were pushed to go to vote, though Bhashani thought his decision to boycott elections in such a crisis would garner huge public support.
Strategic political considerations and calculations
Did Bhashani boycott the general election in understanding with Sheikh Mujib? Was his decision an independent political move or a strategy to allow Awami League to emerge as the biggest political force of East Pakistan? These are popular questions.
An interesting account of Bhashani’s actual intention appears in journalist Nurul Kabir’s “The Red Maulana”. Recounting a conversation between Bhashani and his close associate Saiful Islam, Kabir writes that Bhashani believed participation in the election would divide voters into competing camps and intensify political differences. According to this account, Bhashani considered the moment opportune for achieving national independence and believed that allowing Mujib to win could help prevent such divisions.
But not many retrospective testimonies in this regard were found. Neither any authenticated document or contemporary record establishes that Bhashani and Mujib secretly agreed on a joint electoral strategy, nor did the two great leaders ever claim anything like this. Their public positions also suggest that they were pursuing different routes. On 4 December 1970, three days before the historic polls, Bhashani called Mujib to join his movement for an independent East Pakistan from a massive rally in Dhaka. This clearly indicates that the two leaders had different programmes of action. Bhashani wanted an immediate struggle for sovereignty, whereas Mujib continued to pursue his electoral mandate and constitutional demand for autonomy.
If Bhashani and his NAP had participated in the polls, the whole trajectory of the history could be a different one. Prof Serajul Islam Choudhury, in his article “Maulana Bhashani o Tar Rajniti, writes, “The Islamist parties did not, however, receive an insignificant share of the votes. Together, they secured more than 22 per cent of the total votes, although they failed to win a single seat. Had pro-China NAP contested the election, it would have split the vote, potentially allowing the Islamist parties to win several constituencies where they had finished second. Such an outcome would have worked to the advantage of the military rulers. It is learnt that the military rulers provided these parties with not only moral support but also financial assistance.”
It was not only about the projection of Islamic parties’ success, but also the popularity of the NAP’s seasoned leaders could matter amid a series of resignations by progressive stalwarts. Citing Mashiur Rahman Jadu Mia’s commentary, Mohiuddin Ahmed mentions, “Today, I believe that if the party had taken a positive stance on participating in the election from the outset and secured 25 seats, we could have taken effective initiatives and played a meaningful role in resolving regional issues within Pakistan’s state structure. On the other hand, during the struggle for independence, India would not have been able to exercise a monopoly over the establishment of a puppet government, because we would have stood in its way.”
____________________________________________
The writer is a Senior Staff Correspondent at the Daily Sun

Read More
Advertisement